
The biggest problem with The Sarah Connor Chronicles is the constant sense that it didn’t need to be made. While watching it, I’m desperately hoping that the writers have something truly interesting up their sleeves, convinced that if I’m just patient enough, it will all be worth my while.
In the mean time the show is kind of a mixed bag. Terminator fights result in collapsed walls and obliterated furniture; the usual collateral damage when two robots clobber each other. Then there’s the incredibly distracting slasher-film flashes that accompany terminator entrances. I’ve always hated these effects (recently Sunshine; which had at least 30 minutes of flashing were strung together consecutively). It calls attention to itself and slaps you in the head, shouting, “Hey, it’s a movie!!” It wasn’t used in either of the original films (or even the superfluous third film), which seem to otherwise be the visual bible for the show.

Other positive notes include casting. Thomas Dekker plays John pretty straight, and makes him feel like a teenager again, burdened with his fate and rebellious about it. There was a good bit in the second episode where he records a series of voicemail messages, building up to “You’ve reached the future leader of mankind!” Lena Heady’s Sarah is an interesting problem. She’s Sarah Connor in concept, tough yet uncertain, but it’s different from Linda Hamilton’s portrayal. The character doesn’t feel as tortured or raw; her transition between steel and tears is missing something. She feels more reserved, accepting her role in the events to come, but we never saw her find that acceptance.

Finally we come to Summer Glau, the protagonist terminator named Cameron. (Clever. Necessary?) I couldn’t respect myself as a geek if I wasn’t ridiculously excited to see her return to TV as another awkward behaving, ass-kicking character. Yet, I get worried whenever I see River Tam talking to John Connor, or punching a terminator instead of a reaver. It doesn’t happen a lot, and Summer’s got the robotic mannerisms down (swivel head to scan the room, stand up rigidly, speak in unnecessarily complex syntax, stare blankly), but at the physical level the two characters are just too much alike. I’d hate to see Summer stuck playing this same character again. I really hope the writers bring some complexity to the character fast. And, please, no messiah complexes.

All the good and the bad considered, I want this show to work. We really need more sci-fi shows, and something that isn’t a space opera or a show about a secret agency is more than just refreshing. Still, there’s this nagging image I have of Fox execs sitting around a table with a list of movie franchises that haven’t yet been exploited for TV, and nodding their heads.
Update: Since I put my thoughts about The Sarah Connor Chronicles into words, I’ve found myself really looking forward to tomorrow’s episode, which is one the best things a show can accomplish. I guess I’m officially a fan now.
There are no comments yet, maybe you'd like to add one?